Auralee Wallace is beloved for cozy mysteries that blend wit, warmth, and just the right hint of magic. In books like In the Company of Witches and When the Crow's Away, she creates inviting worlds filled with memorable characters, sharp humor, and satisfying mystery.
If you’re looking for more authors who capture that same cozy, magical charm, these writers are well worth adding to your reading list:
If you enjoy Auralee Wallace’s mix of cozy mystery and witchy atmosphere, Juliet Blackwell is an easy next pick. Her novels feature likable heroines, appealing small-town settings, and supernatural touches that feel playful rather than dark.
Start with Secondhand Spirits, the first book in her Witchcraft Mystery series. It introduces Lily Ivory, a witch who owns a vintage clothing shop and keeps finding herself pulled into murder investigations.
Victoria Laurie writes lively mysteries that combine psychic abilities, humor, and brisk plotting. Like Wallace, she has a talent for creating entertaining lead characters who bring personality and charm to every case.
Begin with Abby Cooper, Psychic Eye, which launches the Psychic Eye Mystery series and follows professional psychic Abby Cooper as she gets tangled up in murder investigations.
Heather Blake’s cozy mysteries are full of magic, warmth, and small-town appeal. Readers who enjoy Auralee Wallace’s light, engaging tone will likely appreciate Blake’s inviting worlds and cheerful sense of fun.
Her Wishcraft Mystery series opens with It Takes a Witch, starring Darcy Merriweather, who uses her wish-granting powers to help solve crimes in a quirky seaside community.
Angie Fox leans into humor, supernatural chaos, and fast-moving plots. Her books have an energetic, offbeat feel that should appeal to readers who enjoy Wallace’s lighter touch and lovable heroines.
The Accidental Demon Slayer, the first in Fox’s Demon Slayer series, follows Lizzie Brown as she discovers hidden powers and stumbles into a wildly funny battle against demons.
Amanda M. Lee writes witty paranormal cozies packed with eccentric characters, magical twists, and plenty of small-town charm. Her stories share the same easy readability and playful spirit that make Auralee Wallace’s books so enjoyable.
Try Any Witch Way You Can, which introduces Bay Winchester, a psychic witch living in a delightfully odd town where unusual mysteries are never far away.
Sofie Kelly is a great choice if you love cozy mysteries with a whimsical streak. Her books are warm, funny, and full of appealing characters, with magical cats adding extra personality and charm.
In Curiosity Thrilled the Cat, librarian Kathleen Paulson and her extraordinary feline companions investigate mysteries in a cozy setting that feels both comforting and magical.
Gigi Pandian brings a clever, inventive touch to the cozy mystery genre. Her books often mix imaginative premises, quirky characters, and satisfying puzzles, making them a strong match for readers who enjoy Wallace’s blend of charm and originality.
In The Accidental Alchemist, a centuries-old alchemist joins forces with a gargoyle chef to solve mysteries in a story that feels fresh, funny, and delightfully unusual.
Annabel Chase writes supernatural cozies with humor, warmth, and plenty of magical mayhem. Fans of Auralee Wallace’s lively casts and lighthearted tone will likely enjoy Chase’s playful approach.
In Curse the Day, lawyer Emma Hart navigates an enchanted town populated by witches, vampires, and other magical beings, all while trying to untangle a mystery.
Bailey Cates combines culinary coziness with a dash of magic, creating mysteries that feel especially inviting. If you like Wallace’s sense of community and charm, Cates is a natural fit.
In Brownies and Broomsticks, baker Katie Lightfoot discovers her magical heritage and begins solving mysteries with the help of both recipes and spellcraft.
Lynn Cahoon writes cozy mysteries centered on relatable characters, close-knit communities, and a gentle sense of humor. While her stories are less overtly magical, they share the welcoming atmosphere Wallace fans often love.
In Guidebook to Murder, Jill Gardner finds herself investigating crime amid the friendships, routines, and secrets of a small-town setting.
Jenn McKinlay delivers cozy mysteries that are breezy, charming, and full of personality. Her books balance humor, friendship, and intriguing puzzles in a way that should appeal to Auralee Wallace readers.
Start with Books Can Be Deceiving, where librarian Lindsey Norris investigates the murder of a local author in a bookish, inviting setting.
Esme Addison blends mystery with magical realism, family secrets, and strong community ties. Her stories have a warm, immersive quality that makes them especially appealing for readers who enjoy cozies with an enchanted edge.
Her novel A Spell for Trouble introduces Aleksandra Daniels, who returns to Bellamy Bay and uncovers hidden family history, local mysteries, and unexpected magic.
Deanna Chase writes light paranormal mysteries filled with whimsical magic, quirky characters, and plenty of small-town appeal. Her books offer a satisfying mix of suspense and fun, much like Wallace’s.
A good place to begin is Witching for Grace, in which Grace Valentine balances crafting, magic, and murder as she tries to solve a mystery close to home.
Adele Abbott specializes in humorous paranormal cozies with witty heroines and delightfully absurd situations. Her playful tone makes her a strong recommendation for readers who enjoy Auralee Wallace’s lighter, more comedic side.
In Witch Is When It All Began, Jill Gooder discovers she has witchy abilities and soon finds herself navigating both magic and mystery.
Leighann Dobbs writes cozy mysteries packed with humor, quirky characters, and plenty of heart. Her stories are quick, enjoyable reads, often set in inviting communities with amateur sleuths you can easily root for.
In Killer Cupcakes, Lexy Baker puts her baking talents to use while investigating a murder close to home, making this a comforting and entertaining choice for Wallace fans.
