Adriana Mather writes atmospheric young adult fiction that blends history, mystery, and a touch of the supernatural. In How to Hang a Witch, she ties Salem’s haunted past to a modern-day story packed with secrets, tension, and sharp twists.
If you enjoy Adriana Mather’s books, these authors are well worth adding to your reading list:
Karen M. McManus is a great pick for readers who love high-stakes mysteries layered with teen drama. Her novel One of Us Is Lying begins with five students walking into detention, but only four walking out alive.
Each of the surviving teens has something to hide, and every secret adds another layer of suspicion after the fifth student dies. As the investigation unfolds, the question isn’t just who did it, but how far each character will go to protect the truth.
With tense pacing, memorable characters, and plenty of surprises, McManus delivers the kind of addictive suspense Adriana Mather fans often crave.
Maureen Johnson writes clever mysteries filled with wit, tension, and vividly drawn teen protagonists. In Truly Devious, she introduces Stevie Bell, a true-crime obsessed student newly enrolled at Ellingham Academy, a prestigious school for gifted learners.
Stevie arrives determined to solve a notorious kidnapping and murder case tied to the school’s founder. But as fresh danger stirs on campus, she discovers that the past may not be finished with Ellingham after all.
If you like Adriana Mather’s mix of dark history, intriguing puzzles, and strong atmosphere, Johnson’s work should be a natural fit.
Holly Jackson is known for twisty, fast-moving mysteries that feel both smart and immediate. Her novel A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder follows high school senior Pip Fitz-Amobi as she reopens a murder case everyone in her town thinks is already solved.
Five years earlier, popular student Andie Bell was killed, and the blame fell on her boyfriend. Pip isn’t convinced the official story is true, and the deeper she digs into interviews, evidence, and old assumptions, the more dangerous her search becomes.
Readers who enjoy Adriana Mather’s balance of teen perspective, suspense, and hidden secrets will likely race through Jackson’s books.
Kara Thomas is an excellent choice for readers drawn to dark, character-centered mysteries. She has a gift for building tension while slowly revealing the lies and grief simmering beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary towns. One especially gripping read is The Cheerleaders.
The novel follows Monica, who is still haunted by the deaths of five cheerleaders from her town. Although everyone else seems ready to leave the past behind, Monica begins uncovering clues that suggest the story was never as simple as it seemed.
As the mystery deepens, Thomas keeps the suspense tight and the emotional stakes high. Fans of Adriana Mather’s eerie intrigue will find a lot to like here.
Kerri Maniscalco writes richly atmospheric fiction that combines historical detail, mystery, and a touch of romance. Readers who love Adriana Mather’s blend of the past and the uncanny will likely enjoy Stalking Jack the Ripper.
Set in Victorian London, the story follows Audrey Rose Wadsworth, a young woman secretly studying forensic medicine despite the expectations placed on her by society. Before long, she becomes entangled in the investigation of the notorious Jack the Ripper murders.
As Audrey Rose hunts for answers, she also faces family secrets, social constraints, and danger at every turn.
The vivid setting and lively chemistry between Audrey Rose and Thomas Cresswell make this an especially entertaining read for fans of historical suspense.
Jessica Goodman writes sharp, fast-paced young adult thrillers filled with privilege, betrayal, and buried secrets.
Her novel They Wish They Were Us follows Jill Newman as she navigates the treacherous social world of an elite high school while still living in the shadow of her best friend’s murder.
Set in a wealthy community where status can hide all kinds of ugliness, the story peels back layers of loyalty, manipulation, and long-buried truth.
If you enjoy Adriana Mather’s mystery-driven storytelling and dangerous teen dynamics, Goodman’s books are a strong next choice.
Caleb Roehrig writes suspenseful YA thrillers that pair emotional honesty with dark twists. His stories often focus on teens caught in situations that spiral quickly out of control.
In Last Seen Leaving Flynn’s girlfriend, January, disappears without explanation. As the investigation intensifies, suspicion starts closing in on Flynn, forcing him to confront secrets in both January’s life and his own.
Roehrig keeps the mystery moving while also exploring identity, trust, and friendship. For readers who like Adriana Mather’s blend of suspense and character depth, his work is well worth a look.
Courtney Summers is known for emotionally powerful young adult novels that don’t shy away from darkness. Her stories feature complex characters, urgent stakes, and an intensity that lingers.
In Sadie, a determined teenager sets out to find her younger sister’s killer and then vanishes herself.
At the same time, a podcast host launches an investigation into Sadie’s disappearance, creating a story that unfolds through multiple perspectives and growing dread.
Readers who appreciate Adriana Mather’s suspense and strong narrative voice may find Summers’ work equally compelling.
Tiffany D. Jackson writes gripping thrillers with unforgettable teen voices and strong emotional weight.
If you enjoyed Adriana Mather’s ability to combine mystery with tension and relatable characters, Monday’s Not Coming is an excellent place to start.
The novel follows Claudia, whose best friend Monday has disappeared. Strangely, no one else seems alarmed, and as Claudia searches for answers, she uncovers painful truths about friendship, family, and the ways people can be overlooked.
Jackson builds a haunting, urgent mystery while also tackling real-world issues, making her books both absorbing and thought-provoking.
Dana Mele is a strong recommendation for readers who enjoy tense, twist-filled mysteries with sharp social dynamics. Her debut novel, People Like Us, centers on Kay Donovan, a popular student at a prestigious boarding school.
When a classmate is found dead in a nearby lake, Kay is drawn into a sinister scavenger hunt seemingly orchestrated by the victim.
As secrets come to light, alliances fracture and Kay’s carefully managed image begins to crack. With high stakes and plenty of surprises, this is a satisfying pick for fans of suspenseful YA fiction.
Kendare Blake is a standout choice for readers who enjoy dark fantasy threaded with mystery and menace. If Adriana Mather’s supernatural edge appeals to you, Anna Dressed in Blood is especially worth checking out.
The story follows Cas Lowood, a teen ghost hunter who tracks deadly spirits from one haunted place to the next. His latest target is Anna, a terrifying ghost said to kill anyone who steps inside her old house.
But Anna is far more complicated than the rumors suggest, and her history gradually reveals a tragedy at the heart of the horror.
Blake creates a chilling atmosphere while keeping the characters grounded and engaging, making this a memorable read for anyone who likes eerie stories with heart.
Mindy McGinnis writes intense, atmospheric novels that often combine mystery with unsettling historical detail. Readers who enjoy Adriana Mather’s darker side may be especially drawn to her work. A Madness So Discreet is one of her standout titles.
Set in a Boston asylum during the Victorian era, the novel follows Grace Mae, a young woman carrying painful secrets into an already disturbing environment. Her intelligence draws the attention of a doctor studying criminal psychology, and together they become involved in a murder investigation.
The result is a compelling blend of history, psychological tension, and character depth that keeps the pages turning.
E. Lockhart writes stylish, emotionally charged stories filled with mystery and revelation. Fans of Adriana Mather may especially enjoy the way Lockhart builds tension through memory, family conflict, and slowly uncovered truth.
In We Were Liars, Cadence Sinclair spends her summers on her wealthy family’s private island. After a mysterious accident, she returns unable to remember what happened during the previous season.
As Cadence pieces together the events of that summer, the novel explores love, privilege, family pressure, and betrayal before arriving at a devastating twist.
Kit Frick writes thoughtful thrillers that rely as much on atmosphere and uncertainty as on plot twists. If you like Adriana Mather’s suspenseful style, Frick is well worth trying.
In I Killed Zoe Spanos, Anna Cicconi becomes entangled in the mystery of Zoe Spanos, a missing girl from a picturesque Hamptons town.
As Anna starts uncovering connections between Zoe’s life and her own fragmented memories, the story grows increasingly tense and disorienting. It’s a slow-burn mystery with a strong payoff for readers who enjoy psychological suspense.
Jennifer Lynn Barnes is an easy recommendation for readers who enjoy mysteries packed with puzzles, secrets, and sharp character dynamics.
In her novel The Inheritance Games, Avery Grambs unexpectedly inherits a billionaire’s fortune despite having no apparent connection to him.
She is suddenly thrust into a mansion full of hidden passages, coded clues, and four disinherited grandsons who are just as baffled as she is. The result is a clever, fast-moving mystery fueled by family intrigue and constant reversals.
Barnes brings energy, suspense, and plenty of fun to the story, making this a great pick for anyone who enjoys smart YA mysteries.
